RESUMO
La violencia contra los niños es una preocupación muy importante en el sistema de salud pública. El filicidio es un acto deliberado de una madre o un padre que mata a su propio hijo. El objetivo de este estudio es describir un caso de filicidio asociado a la presencia del Trastorno Límite de la Personalidad (TLP), analizando la evaluación de la imputabilidad criminal relacionada con este caso, utilizando el criterio biopsicológico. Medidas de protección a los niños deben ser ofrecidas de forma activa cuando los padres tienen estrés y falta de equilibrio emocional, y al mismo tiempo deben cuidar a los niños.
Violence against children is a very important concern in the public health system. Filicide is a deliberate act of a mother or father killing his own child. The aim of this study is to describe a case of filicide associated with the presence of borderline personality disorder, discussing the evaluation of criminal imputability related to this case, using the biopsychological criterion. Child protection measures should be actively offered when parents have stress and lack of emotional balance while needing to care for children.
RESUMO
Resumo Conhecer o paradigma ético que fundamenta o código moral da medicina é fundamental para atuar não só na assistência, mas também em processo pericial. A partir de revisão da literatura, propõe-se avaliar a maneira como os quatro princípios éticos fundamentais (beneficência, não maleficência, autonomia e justiça) se aplicam antes, durante e após a perícia psiquiátrica, como perito ou como assistente técnico. Novos desafios éticos vêm surgindo na psiquiatria forense. Com a pandemia de covid-19, a tecnologia foi adotada para permitir a prática da telemedicina, mas ainda se debate se seria suficiente para promover avaliação pericial psiquiátrica adequada. Considerando a complexidade da área, cada situação deve ser analisada de forma individual e abrangente, sendo recomendável buscar auxílio para debater as perspectivas éticas e legais das perícias psiquiátricas quando necessário.
Abstract Knowing the ethical paradigm that bases the medicine moral code is fundamental to act not only in care but also in the expert testimony process. From a revision of the literature, we propose to evaluate the way the four fundamental ethical principles (beneficence, nonmaleficence, autonomy, and justice) apply before, during, and after the psychiatric expert testimony, be it as expert or as technical assistant. New ethical challenges have been appearing in forensic psychiatry. With the COVID-19 pandemic, technology was adopted to allow the practice of telemedicine, but debates still occur if that would suffice for an adequate psychiatric expert testimony evaluation. Considering the complexity of the area, each situation must be analyzed in an individualized and all-encompassing way and seeking help to debate the ethical and legal perspectives of psychiatric expert testimonies is recommended when necessary.
Resumen Conocer el paradigma ético que subyace en el código moral de la medicina es fundamental para actuar no solo en la asistencia, sino también en el proceso pericial. A partir de una revisión bibliográfica, se propone evaluar cómo se aplican los cuatro principios éticos fundamentales (beneficencia, no maleficencia, autonomía y justicia) antes, durante y después de la pericia psiquiátrica, ya sea como perito o como asistente técnico. Están surgiendo nuevos desafíos éticos en la psiquiatría forense. Con la pandemia del Covid-19, se utilizó la tecnología para permitir la práctica de la telemedicina, pero aún está en debate si esto es suficiente para promover una adecuada evaluación psiquiátrica forense. Considerando la complejidad del área, se debe analizar cada situación de manera individual e integral y, cuando sea necesario, buscar ayuda para debatir las perspectivas éticas y legales de la pericia psiquiátrica.
Assuntos
Psiquiatria Legal , Teoria Ética , Ética , Prova Pericial , Medicina Legal , Princípios MoraisRESUMO
The combination of severe personality disorders and violence poses a challenge for mental health services, including forensic services and community mental health services. In the context of COVID-19 pandemic, after observing the alarming number of cases of coronavirus and deaths in Brazil, we aimed to discuss the potential increase in hostile behavior, violence and crime in individuals with personality disorders. A literature review was conducted on antisocial and borderline personality disorders and the possible implications on violent behavior of these personality disorders, during the Covid-19 pandemic. We reviewed Medline database articles on these topics between the years 2000 and 2020. During the pandemic it is important that these services be attentive and prepared for new demands and worsening of previously stabilized individuals of borderline personality disorder and antissocial personality disorder.(AU)
A combinação de transtornos de personalidade grave e violência representa um desafio para os serviços de saúde mental, incluindo os serviços forenses e os serviços comunitários de saúde mental. No contexto da pandemia do COVID-19, após observar o número alarmante de casos de coronavírus e mortes no Brasil, objetivamos discutir o potencial aumento do comportamento hostil, da violência e da criminalidade em indivíduos com transtornos de personalidade. Foi realizada uma revisão da literatura sobre os transtornos borderline e antisocial e as possíveis implicações no comportamento violento desses transtornos de personalidade durante a pandemia do Covid-19. Revisamos artigos da base de dados Medline sobre esses temas, entre os anos 2000 e 2020. Durante a pandemia é importante que esses serviços fiquem atentos e estejam preparados para novas demandas e agravamento de indivíduos previamente estabilizados de transtorno borderline de personalidade e transtorno de personalidade antissocial.(AU)
La combinación de trastornos graves de personalidad y violencia plantea un desafío para los servicios de salud mental, incluidos los servicios forenses y los servicios comunitarios de salud mental. En el contexto de la pandemia COVID-19, después de observar el alarmante número de casos y muertes de coronavirus en Brasil, nos propusimos discutir el posible aumento de la conducta hostil, la violencia y la delincuencia en individuos con trastornos de personalidad. Se realizó una revisión de la literatura sobre trastornos limítrofes y antisociales y las posibles implicaciones en el comportamiento violento de estos trastornos de la personalidad durante la pandemia de Covid-19. Se revisaron artículos de la base de datos Medline sobre estos temas entre los años 2000 y 2020. Durante la pandemia es importante que estos servicios estén atentos y preparados para nuevas demandas y el empeoramiento de individuos previamente estabilizados de trastorno límite de la personalidad y trastorno antisocial de la personalidad.(AU)
Assuntos
Violência , Transtorno da Personalidade Borderline , COVID-19 , Transtorno da Personalidade AntissocialRESUMO
Violence committed by individuals with severe mental disorders has become a growing focus of interest among physicians, law enforcement officials, and the general population. Homicide involving relatives, specially parricide, matricide, and filicide, despite the relatively low incidence of these crimes, may be enigmatic, so forensic psychiatrist are frequently called on the courts to answer questions about insanity and criminal responsibility. The current study aims to describe Brazilian cases of parricide, matricide, and filicide associated with presence of major mental disorders and personality disorders, discussing the assessment of criminal responsibility in each case. The case series described were specifically related to people with mental illness, as bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, and borderline personality with comorbidity of drug abuse. Two of them were considered not guilty by reason of insanity, and the other one was considered partially criminally responsible, according to Brazilian Law and Forensic Psychiatric Reports of the cases. The justice determined compulsory psychiatric treatment for all of them. The question of criminal responsibility of individuals with mental disorders is challenging for criminal justice, psychiatry, and society. Adequate treatment is mandatory to prevent crimes involving mental disorders, as shown in literature. The verification of criminal responsibility is essential for persons' adequate referral in any system of criminal law, thus protecting human rights and referring those who need psychiatric treatment.