RESUMO

BACKGROUND: The main goal of a health system is to maintain or improve people's health. The COVID-19 pandemic showed the fragility of health systems worldwide. In Mexico, the pandemic affected the performance of the health system, along with the presence of contextual conditions such as its segmentation and high prevalence of chronic diseases. AIMS: To analyze from an approach to the functions of the health system, the service delivery, human resources, financing, and stewardship/governance in the local health services of five states of Mexico, from the perspective of the staff working in health centers. METHODS: This is an exploratory qualitative study conducted from November 2020 to August 2021, involving 124 health professionals from 39 health facilities (18 rural and 21 urban). The technique used was the semi-structured interview. Interview guides were developed according to core topics. Subsequently, the thematic analysis method was used. RESULTS: The lack of financial resources delayed prevention efforts and made it difficult for health centers to adapt to the crisis. Inequity was found in the distributive efficiency of staff between rural and urban areas and levels of care. In addition, there was evidence of capacity for coordination, capacity sharing, and joint participation between health institutions, civil authorities, and the population to face the emergency. CONCLUSIONS: We identified relevant public health actions that showed the capacity of local health services to organize a response to the pandemic at the level of the actors responsible for these services.

Assuntos

RESUMO

The concept of resilience was applied to the public health field to investigate the way health systems are impacted by health crises, what conditions allow them to mitigate the blow and how they reorganize once the crisis is over. In 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic caused by the SARS-CoV-2 virus represented a global challenge demanding immediate response to an unprecedented health crisis. Various voices drew attention to the intensity of the crisis in countries with greater inequalities, where the pandemic converged with other social emergencies. We documented the experiences of health personnel who faced the pandemic at the primary care level while simultaneously maintaining the functioning of other areas of medical care. Our results derived from a qualitative study comprising 103 participants from five states of Mexico. We aimed to show through inferential analysis their perspective on what we call 'the resilience of local health systems'. We observed three stages of experience during the crisis: (a) Preparation (official guidelines received to organize care, training and planning of epidemiological surveillance); (b) Adaptation (performance of community-based prevention activities, infrastructure modifications, telehealth); and (c) Learning (participatory governance with city councils, business sector and organized population). The study suggests that the local health systems analysed benefited from the initiatives of health personnel that in some cases positively exceeded their duties. In terms of the resilience analysis, they were able to handle the impact of the crisis and cope with it. Their transformative capacity came from the strategies implemented to adapt health services by managing institutional resources. Their experience represents a lesson on the strengthening of the essential functions of health systems and shows a way to address successfully the increasingly complex health challenges of the present and future times.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Poor nutritional conditions persist in many Mayan communities in Yucatán, Mexico, even though various programs have been implemented. The study aimed to compare the effects of a community-based nutritional intervention with an intercultural focus versus a conventional nutritional intervention on body mass index (BMI) and diet in women in Mayan communities in Yucatán. The sample included adult women with BMI ≥ 25kg/m2 from neighboring rural Mayan villages. Both interventions lasted three months with 11 sessions and followed the prevailing guidelines. The community-based intervention used an intercultural tool called Good Mayan Food [Plato del Bien Comer Maya], besides strategies designed according to information obtained from a prior qualitative study phase using interviews. The group that received the community-based intervention (n = 7), compared to the conventional intervention group (n = 9), showed larger decreases in BMI (-0.58 ± 0.70 kg/m2 and +0.27 ± 0.64kg/m2; p = 0.042), waist circumference (-2.15 ± 2.60 cm and -0.50 ± 0.75 cm; p = 0.042), and consumption of fats (-53.23 ± 21.92 grams and -7.34 ± 25.77 grams; p = 0.004), as well as higher increases in weekly consumption of some local foods such as nance fruit (p = 0.012), tamarind (p = 0.001), and chili peppers (p = 0.004). The community-based intervention was the only one to show a significant decrease in daily calorie intake (baseline: 2,067 ± 91 kcal/day, at three months: 1,474 ± 31 kcal/day; p = 0.018), and both groups showed decreases in the consumption of ultra-processed foods, but without significant differences between the two groups. The community-based intervention group showed better results than the conventional intervention group.

Las malas condiciones nutricionales en muchas localidades mayas de Yucatán, México, persisten, a pesar de que se han implementado diversos programas. El objetivo fue comparar los efectos de una intervención nutricional basada en la comunidad con enfoque intercultural (INBC) y una intervención nutricional convencional (INC), sobre el índice de masa corporal (IMC) y la dieta en mujeres de localidades mayas de Yucatán. Fueron incluidas mujeres adultas con IMC ≥ 25kg/m2 de dos pequeñas localidades rurales mayas vecinas. Ambas intervenciones fueron de tres meses y con 11 sesiones, siguiendo la normatividad vigente; en la INBC fue utilizada la herramienta intercultural, denominada Plato del Bien Comer Maya, además se incluyeron en la INBC estrategias diseñadas con base en información obtenida en una fase previa de estudio cualitativo con entrevistas. El grupo con la INBC (n = 7), en comparación con el grupo con la INC (n = 9), tuvo una mayor disminución de IMC (-0,58 ± 0,70 kg/m2 y +0,27 ± 0,64 kg/m2; p = 0,042), de la circunferencia de cintura (-2,15 ± 2,60 cm y -0,50 ± 0,75 cm; p = 0,042) y del consumo de grasas (-53,23 ± 21,92 gramos y -7,34 ± 25,77 gramos; p = 0,004), así como mayor incremento en las frecuencias semanales de consumo de algunos alimentos locales como nance (p = 0,012), tamarindo (p = 0,001) y chile (p = 0,004), la INBC fue la única que presentó una disminución significativa en el consumo diario de calorías (basal: 2.067 ± 91 kcal/día, a los tres meses: 1.474 ± 31 kcal/día; p = 0,018), hubo en ambos grupos disminuciones en el consumo de alimentos ultraprocesados, pero sin diferencias comparando los grupos; el grupo con la INBC obtuvo mejores resultados que el grupo con la INC.

As más condições nutricionais em muitas localidades maias de Yucatán (México) persistem apesar da implementação de diversos programas. O objetivo era comparar os impactos de uma intervenção nutricional baseada na comunidade com enfoque intercultural (INBC) e uma intervenção nutricional convencional (INC), sobre o índice de massa corporal (IMC) e a dieta de mulheres de localidades maias de Yucatán. Foram incluídas mulheres adultas com IMC ≥ 25kg/m2 de duas pequenas localidades rurais maias vizinhas. Ambas as intervenções duraram três meses e contaram com 11 sessões, conforme as normas vigentes; na INBC, foi utilizada a ferramenta intercultural denominada Prato de Comer Bem Maia [Plato del Bien Comer Maya], além de estratégias adicionais idealizadas com base em dados obtidos em uma fase prévia de estudo qualitativo com entrevistas. Em comparação com o grupo com a INC (n = 9), o grupo com a INBC (n = 7) teve maior diminuição de IMC (-0,58 ± 0,70 kg/m2 e +0,27 ± 0,64 kg/m2; p = 0,042), da circunferência abdominal (-2,15 ± 2,60 cm y -0,50 ± 0,75 cm; p = 0,042) e do consumo de gorduras (-53,23 ± 21,92 gramas y -7,34 ± 25,77 gramas; p = 0,004), bem como um aumento maior das frequências semanais de consumo de alguns alimentos locais como o murici (p = 0,012), o tamarindo (p = 0,001) e pimenta (p = 0,004). A INBC foi a única a apresentar uma diminuição significativa do consumo diário de calorias (inicial: 2.067 ± 91 kcal/dia, após três meses: 1.474 ± 31 kcal/dia; p = 0.018). Houve em ambos os grupos redução equivalente do consumo de alimentos ultraprocessados; o grupo com a INBC obteve melhores resultados que o grupo com a INC.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Vulnerability is a concept associated with the effects of social inequities to access health care services. On a hospital level, vulnerable populations must be identified and favored over others. The aims of this study were the analysis of the conceptions and practices of social workers regarding vulnerable patients, and the identification of theoretical elements of vulnerability given by academics. Hospital ethnography and a focus group were implemented. Social workers related vulnerability to the social needs of each patient; however, they state that they have dilemmas to identify a person in a vulnerable condition; these dilemmas are related to social differences and deservingness. Academics indicated that the vulnerability should refer to the lack of access to health services offered by the institution. Academics agree with social workers regarding the importance of considering the overlapped social and individual circumstances in each patient to recognize their vulnerable condition, regardless of belonging to any of the pre-established vulnerable groups. Finally, taking into account the way of conceptualizing vulnerability and how public policy on the identification of vulnerable patients in the hospital has been implemented, these two elements are explained using the palimpsest model, which is a figure of thought that can be applied to analyze the sociocultural significance of this complex issue, as well as other social dynamics.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Las malas condiciones nutricionales en muchas localidades mayas de Yucatán, México, persisten, a pesar de que se han implementado diversos programas. El objetivo fue comparar los efectos de una intervención nutricional basada en la comunidad con enfoque intercultural (INBC) y una intervención nutricional convencional (INC), sobre el índice de masa corporal (IMC) y la dieta en mujeres de localidades mayas de Yucatán. Fueron incluidas mujeres adultas con IMC ≥ 25kg/m2 de dos pequeñas localidades rurales mayas vecinas. Ambas intervenciones fueron de tres meses y con 11 sesiones, siguiendo la normatividad vigente; en la INBC fue utilizada la herramienta intercultural, denominada Plato del Bien Comer Maya, además se incluyeron en la INBC estrategias diseñadas con base en información obtenida en una fase previa de estudio cualitativo con entrevistas. El grupo con la INBC (n = 7), en comparación con el grupo con la INC (n = 9), tuvo una mayor disminución de IMC (-0,58 ± 0,70 kg/m2 y +0,27 ± 0,64 kg/m2; p = 0,042), de la circunferencia de cintura (-2,15 ± 2,60 cm y -0,50 ± 0,75 cm; p = 0,042) y del consumo de grasas (-53,23 ± 21,92 gramos y -7,34 ± 25,77 gramos; p = 0,004), así como mayor incremento en las frecuencias semanales de consumo de algunos alimentos locales como nance (p = 0,012), tamarindo (p = 0,001) y chile (p = 0,004), la INBC fue la única que presentó una disminución significativa en el consumo diario de calorías (basal: 2.067 ± 91 kcal/día, a los tres meses: 1.474 ± 31 kcal/día; p = 0,018), hubo en ambos grupos disminuciones en el consumo de alimentos ultraprocesados, pero sin diferencias comparando los grupos; el grupo con la INBC obtuvo mejores resultados que el grupo con la INC.

Poor nutritional conditions persist in many Mayan communities in Yucatán, Mexico, even though various programs have been implemented. The study aimed to compare the effects of a community-based nutritional intervention with an intercultural focus versus a conventional nutritional intervention on body mass index (BMI) and diet in women in Mayan communities in Yucatán. The sample included adult women with BMI ≥ 25kg/m2 from neighboring rural Mayan villages. Both interventions lasted three months with 11 sessions and followed the prevailing guidelines. The community-based intervention used an intercultural tool called Good Mayan Food [Plato del Bien Comer Maya], besides strategies designed according to information obtained from a prior qualitative study phase using interviews. The group that received the community-based intervention (n = 7), compared to the conventional intervention group (n = 9), showed larger decreases in BMI (-0.58 ± 0.70 kg/m2 and +0.27 ± 0.64kg/m2; p = 0.042), waist circumference (-2.15 ± 2.60 cm and -0.50 ± 0.75 cm; p = 0.042), and consumption of fats (-53.23 ± 21.92 grams and -7.34 ± 25.77 grams; p = 0.004), as well as higher increases in weekly consumption of some local foods such as nance fruit (p = 0.012), tamarind (p = 0.001), and chili peppers (p = 0.004). The community-based intervention was the only one to show a significant decrease in daily calorie intake (baseline: 2,067 ± 91 kcal/day, at three months: 1,474 ± 31 kcal/day; p = 0.018), and both groups showed decreases in the consumption of ultra-processed foods, but without significant differences between the two groups. The community-based intervention group showed better results than the conventional intervention group.

As más condições nutricionais em muitas localidades maias de Yucatán (México) persistem apesar da implementação de diversos programas. O objetivo era comparar os impactos de uma intervenção nutricional baseada na comunidade com enfoque intercultural (INBC) e uma intervenção nutricional convencional (INC), sobre o índice de massa corporal (IMC) e a dieta de mulheres de localidades maias de Yucatán. Foram incluídas mulheres adultas com IMC ≥ 25kg/m2 de duas pequenas localidades rurais maias vizinhas. Ambas as intervenções duraram três meses e contaram com 11 sessões, conforme as normas vigentes; na INBC, foi utilizada a ferramenta intercultural denominada Prato de Comer Bem Maia [Plato del Bien Comer Maya], além de estratégias adicionais idealizadas com base em dados obtidos em uma fase prévia de estudo qualitativo com entrevistas. Em comparação com o grupo com a INC (n = 9), o grupo com a INBC (n = 7) teve maior diminuição de IMC (-0,58 ± 0,70 kg/m2 e +0,27 ± 0,64 kg/m2; p = 0,042), da circunferência abdominal (-2,15 ± 2,60 cm y -0,50 ± 0,75 cm; p = 0,042) e do consumo de gorduras (-53,23 ± 21,92 gramas y -7,34 ± 25,77 gramas; p = 0,004), bem como um aumento maior das frequências semanais de consumo de alguns alimentos locais como o murici (p = 0,012), o tamarindo (p = 0,001) e pimenta (p = 0,004). A INBC foi a única a apresentar uma diminuição significativa do consumo diário de calorias (inicial: 2.067 ± 91 kcal/dia, após três meses: 1.474 ± 31 kcal/dia; p = 0.018). Houve em ambos os grupos redução equivalente do consumo de alimentos ultraprocessados; o grupo com a INBC obteve melhores resultados que o grupo com a INC.

Assuntos

RESUMO

At the end of December 2019, SARS-COV-2 virus was identified as responsible for the COVID-19 pandemic. The rapid spread of transmission exposed structural failures of modern societies and of the health systems in preventing and containing a health threat. Scientific discussion has focused on the search for a vaccine, but less on understanding the social response to the current global threat and fear of outbreaks. In this essay, we reflect, based on the social sciences, on the importance of linking three concepts: vulnerability-perception-risk. This is necessary to develop preventive strategies appropriate to population circumstances, especially with the most vulnerable population, in favor of health equity.

A finales de diciembre 2019 se identificó el virus SARS-COV-2 como responsable de la pandemia de Covid-19. La rápida expansión de la transmisión puso al descubierto fallas estructurales de las sociedades modernas y de los sistemas de salud para prevenir y contener una amenaza sanitaria. La discusión científica se ha concentrado en la búsqueda de una vacuna, pero menos en comprender la respuesta social ante la amenaza globalizada actual y el temor a los rebrotes. En este ensayo reflexionamos, desde las ciencias sociales, sobre la importancia de vincular tres conceptos: vulnerabilidad-percepción-riesgo. Esto es necesario para desarrollar estrategias preventivas adecuadas a las circunstancias poblacionales, especialmente con la población más vulnerable, a favor de la equidad en salud.

No final de dezembro de 2019, o vírus SARS-COV-2 foi identificado como responsável pela pandemia de Covid-19. A rápida propagação da transmissão expôs falhas estruturais das sociedades modernas e dos sistemas de saúde na prevenção e contenção de uma ameaça sanitária. A discussão científica tem se concentrado na busca por uma vacina, mas menos na compreensão da resposta social à atual ameaça global e ao medo de novos surtos. Neste ensaio refletimos, a partir das ciências sociais, sobre a importância de associar três conceitos: vulnerabilidade-percepção-risco. Isso é necessário para desenvolver estratégias preventivas adequadas às circunstâncias da população, principalmente junto à população mais vulnerável, em prol da equidade na saúde.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Resumen: Objetivo: Reflexionar sobre el apoyo emocional que los Grupos de Ayuda Mutua (GAM) dan a personas indígenas con diabetes y su importancia en el apego al tratamiento. Material y métodos: Estudio cualitativo: 25 entrevistas semiestructuradas; tres grupos focales (17 participantes); y observación no participante. Se realizó análisis de contenido con el apoyo del programa Atlas-ti. Resultados: Se identificaron expresiones emocionales relacionadas con el padecimiento. La opinión sobre el trabajo grupal fue positiva. El GAM es un espacio de catarsis, pero no funciona como soporte para enfrentar las restricciones del tratamiento y el impacto emocional en caso de complicaciones mayores. Conclusiones: Con la debida capacitación del personal de salud a cargo de los grupos, los GAM pueden llegar a ser espacios de soporte emocional para las personas indígenas y contribuir a su bienestar.

Abstract: Objective: To think about the emotional support that Mutual Aid Groups (MAG) offer up to indigenous people with diabetes and their importance in adherence to treatment. Materials and methods: Qualitative study: 25 semi-structured interviews; 3 focus groups (17 participants); and non-participant observation. Content analysis was carried out with the support of the Atlas-ti program. Results: We identified emotional expressions related to the disease. The opinion about MAGs and group work was positive. The MAG is a catharsis space, but it does not work as a support to face the restrictions of the treatment and the emotional impact in case of major complications. Conclusions: With proper training of the health personnel in charge of the groups, MAGs can become emotional support spaces for indigenous people and contribute to their well-being.

RESUMO

RESUMEN A finales de diciembre 2019 se identificó el virus SARS-COV-2 como responsable de la pandemia de Covid-19. La rápida expansión de la transmisión puso al descubierto fallas estructurales de las sociedades modernas y de los sistemas de salud para prevenir y contener una amenaza sanitaria. La discusión científica se ha concentrado en la búsqueda de una vacuna, pero menos en comprender la respuesta social ante la amenaza globalizada actual y el temor a los rebrotes. En este ensayo reflexionamos, desde las ciencias sociales, sobre la importancia de vincular tres conceptos: vulnerabilidad-percepción-riesgo. Esto es necesario para desarrollar estrategias preventivas adecuadas a las circunstancias poblacionales, especialmente con la población más vulnerable, a favor de la equidad en salud.

RESUMO No final de dezembro de 2019, o vírus SARS-COV-2 foi identificado como responsável pela pandemia de Covid-19. A rápida propagação da transmissão expôs falhas estruturais das sociedades modernas e dos sistemas de saúde na prevenção e contenção de uma ameaça sanitária. A discussão científica tem se concentrado na busca por uma vacina, mas menos na compreensão da resposta social à atual ameaça global e ao medo de novos surtos. Neste ensaio refletimos, a partir das ciências sociais, sobre a importância de associar três conceitos: vulnerabilidade-percepção-risco. Isso é necessário para desenvolver estratégias preventivas adequadas às circunstâncias da população, principalmente junto à população mais vulnerável, em prol da equidade na saúde.

ABSTRACT At the end of December 2019, SARS-COV-2 virus was identified as responsible for the COVID-19 pandemic. The rapid spread of transmission exposed structural failures of modern societies and of the health systems in preventing and containing a health threat. Scientific discussion has focused on the search for a vaccine, but less on understanding the social response to the current global threat and fear of outbreaks. In this essay, we reflect, based on the social sciences, on the importance of linking three concepts: vulnerability-perception-risk. This is necessary to develop preventive strategies appropriate to population circumstances, especially with the most vulnerable population, in favor of health equity.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Through quantitative and qualitative methods, in this article the authors describe the perspectives of indigenous women who received antenatal and childbirth medical care within a care model that incorporates a non-governmental organisation (NGO), Partners in Health. They discuss whether the NGO model better resolves the care-seeking process, including access to health care, compared with a standard model of care in government-subsidised health care units (setting of health services networks). Universal health coverage advocates access for the most disadvantaged and vulnerable populations as a priority. However, the issue of access includes problems related to the effect of certain structural social determinants that limit different aspects of the obstetric care process. The findings of this study show the need to modify the structure of organisational values in order to place users at the centre of medical care and ensure respect for their rights. The participation of agents outside the public system, such as NGOs, can be of great value for moving in this direction. Women's participation is also necessary for learning how they are being cared for and the extent to which they are satisfied with obstetric services. This research experience can be used for other countries with similar conditions.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Objetivo. Reflexionar sobre el apoyo emocional que los Grupos de Ayuda Mutua (GAM) dan a personas indígenas con diabetes y su importancia en el apego al tratamiento. Material y métodos. Estudio cualitativo: 25 entrevistas semiestructuradas; tres grupos focales (17 participantes); y observación no participante. Se realizó análisis de contenido con el apoyo del programa Atlas-ti. Resultados. Se identificaron expresiones emocionales relacionadas con el padecimiento. La opinión sobre el trabajo grupal fue positiva. El GAM es un espacio de catarsis, pero no funciona como soporte para enfrentar las restricciones del tratamiento y el impacto emocional en caso de complicaciones mayores. Conclusiones. Con la debida capacitación del personal de salud a cargo de los grupos, los GAM pueden llegar a ser espacios de soporte emocional para las personas indígenas y contribuir a su bienestar.

Assuntos